Reflexive Denial Of Pregnancy Accommodation Requests Increases Liability

Written exclusively for Chubbworks

The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission sued an Ohio toy manufacturer, Step2 Company, LLC, and alleged that a pregnant assembly line worker was not permitted to sit down briefly between assemblies, was not allowed to take more frequent breaks, and was not allowed to avoid working on strenuous assemblies. After these accommodation requests were denied, Step2 allegedly interfered with the pregnant worker's ability to get other accommodations.

The employee was also disciplined under the company's attendance policy because of her pregnancy-related absences and approved medical leave.

The employee was ultimately terminated.

Source: https://www.eeoc.gov/newsroom/eeoc-sues-step2-company-sex-pregnancy-and-disability-discrimination-and-retaliation

Commentary

Brief periods to sit down, more frequent breaks, and reassignment away from physically demanding tasks are low-cost accommodations the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act requires.

Reflexive denial of simple accommodations is often unlawful and a risky choice when accommodations are requested. Organizations should consider the following, instead:

· Start simple accommodations- such as more frequent breaks or more sitting - immediately. These do not require an interactive process.

· Relief from some duties would necessitate an interactive process to explore what reasonable accommodations would allow the employee to perform the duties.

· Document the process.

· Remember, each request for accommodations should be addressed on a case-by-case basis.

· Refresh pregnancy and disability anti-discrimination training, annually

The final takeaway is accommodations are often inexpensive to provide. To help avoid the risks, organizations should engage in the interactive process and avoid reflexive denials.

Finally, your opinion is important to us. Please complete the opinion survey:

What's New

AI Malware May Be The New Hot Scam, But Don't Forget The Classics

AI has been getting much media attention in the cybersecurity sphere; however, the cyber attack basics are still legitimate risks, and they are not going away. We discuss those risks and what organizations need to know.

Malicious File Extensions: Inspect The Bytes, Not The Name

A new phishing campaign is delivering malware inside files that carry a font extension that is not actually a font. We examine how these campaigns bypass cybersecurity controls and what organizations need to know.

Novel AI Malware Presents New Challenges And Requires More From Employers

Cybersecurity experts have identified detection gaps with AI-generated malware. We discuss what makes AI malware unique and how it evades discovery.

Latest Numbers

  • Unemployment Rate
    4.3% in Jan 2026
  • Payroll Employment
    +130,000(p) in Jan 2026
  • Average Hourly Earnings
    +$0.15(p) in Jan 2026
  • Employment Cost Index (ECI)
    +0.7% in 4th Qtr of 2025
  • Productivity
    +4.9% in 3rd Qtr of 2025

Source: Department of Labor